Local actor Shayna Benardo is getting a chance to shine in the new Peacock television series “The Good Daughter.” 

Adapted from the novel of the same name by Karin Slaughter, “The Good Daughter”  follows two sisters, Charlotte (Meghann Fahy) and Samantha (Rose Byrne) still struggling with the aftermath of a violent attack on their family 20 years later. Benardo plays Kelly Wilson, a school shooting suspect who Charlotte, a defense attorney, takes on as a client. Slaughter created the show and adapted the book herself. Each episode is directed by Steph Green.

Originally from Florida, Benardo moved to Georgia to pursue acting right after she graduated college. Ahead of the premiere of “The Good Daughter” on Nov. 12, I spoke to Benardo about her burgeoning career and landing the role. This interview has been edited for length and clarity. 

Shayna Benardo as Kelly Wilson in "The Good Daughter." (Photo by Mark Hill/Peacock)
Shayna Benardo as Kelly Wilson in “The Good Daughter.” (Photo by Mark Hill/Peacock)

When did you decide that you wanted to be an actor? Has this been kind of a lifelong passion for you?

Shayna Benardo: Well, it was one of those lofty dreams that you have as a child – kind of like walking on the moon and being a marine biologist. And some people pursue that; they stick with it. But it was just a fun idea, and I always loved being in theater as a kid. And then I grew up, and it was time for me to pick a major in college. I was genuinely torn between becoming an astronaut [and being an actor]. I wanted to do something challenging!

So, it’s either going to be an astronaut or an actor. I was like, you know what? I’m not sure I actually want to be an astronaut. I think I just want to play one in the movies. So was a wakeup call. And I was like, well, I’m committing to the bit now. Let’s do it.

Where did you go to college, and when did you end up in Georgia?

Benardo: I went to UCF – go Knights, charge on, Orlando. Literally the same weekend that I graduated, I drove up to Atlanta with everything I could fit in my car.

Obviously this is changing, but when you think acting, you think of L.A. or New York. Was that ever a thought for you? 

Benardo: Of course. I mean, years ago, before COVID hit, Atlanta was so much more booming with the film industry. It was becoming the spot, with more projects going on than New York or L.A., and so there was a huge promise there. It’s a great place to get your foot in the door, in Atlanta, because being a local hire, these co-star roles – every credit on your resume is a brick in the wall, and Atlanta felt like the best place to start and the most reasonable place to start for me. Just graduating college, New York and L.A. are expensive. Fortunately, Atlanta is a bit of a reprieve from that. 

So you get here, with all your stuff in your car. What does that star look like for you? How do you get your foot in the door?

Benardo: Oh my gosh! Don’t we all have stories of starting out in a new city, and you’re like, I can’t even leave the house! It’s so overwhelming. It’s hard to get on your feet, especially because I knew very, very few people when I moved here. I was like, big city, big world, gotta figure it out! But I always look for the three core things, which [are] job, physical activity, and an acting class.

So you’re getting out of the house. You’re moving your body. You’re getting into a class where you’re going to meet people who you want to be part of their community, and they might know more than you and be willing to share their knowledge … Eventually, once I unfroze from being so terrified at 21, I was like, let’s go. 

What was your first job? Do you remember the first gig that you got?

Benardo: I feel like the one that stands out is probably “Doom Patrol.” It was my first network credit, which was so exciting and on such an incredible show too.

Obviously there are a lot of challenges in getting started in this industry. What do you think was the biggest hurdle you faced? 

Benardo: I mean, having absolutely no knowledge about the industry and truly being an outsider. I didn’t even know you needed a resume anymore. I was like, people don’t use those things – why do I need a headshot? That sounds so old school. Like, that can’t be how it works. But no one teaches you the steps of starting out, and so that discovery took me a really long time, because I had no one to confirm or deny. I was kind of solo in my journey starting out. 

How did “The Good Daughter” come around for you?

Benardo: I had the audition way back in November 2024. I got the breakdown, and I was like, wow – I don’t fit the physical description for this. But this character is so interesting and so important. I don’t care if I’m a left field audition. I’m gonna take care of this girl and give her as much respect as possible, and do my best to portray her. And fortunately, they liked what they saw. I heard back about a month later in December. We had an in-person callback at Assembly Studios up in Doraville. I didn’t hear anything until January 15, and then my agents called me, broke the news. They were like, “Well, what are you gonna do for the rest of the day?” And I was like, “Well, I have to go to work!” So I went to my restaurant job and poured ranch in cups and cut up lemons. It was the happiest I’ve ever been pouring ranch in cups.

What was it about the character that drew you to her? 

Benardo: She’s just got so many layers. She’s kind of in this in between world of like, is she the villain? Is she innocent? I think balancing that on top of the lens through which she sees life was such an interesting challenge for me. So not only having empathy for this type of person and broadening my perspective, but just getting to sink my teeth into something so interesting was super exciting.

As an actor, what is your approach when you first start tackling a character? What’s the first thing you do, and then what process do you follow? 

Benardo: Well, it’s so different when you are auditioning for co-stars and smaller roles, things like where you’re quote-unquote “delivering the pizza.” You can create a whole backstory for your character, but a lot of the time, it’s more about understanding where the scene fits – [where] this small piece of the puzzle fits into the bigger picture. At the time I was auditioning for few larger roles. I was like, okay – this is my opportunity to really create a character before breaking down the scene as a means to an end. So coming up and doing research for who she is and how she was described as a character and building out that world and then making choices about how I would dissect the scene through Kelly’s eyes with that perspective definitely was a part of my process.

This is based on a book. Did you jump into the novel? I know some people don’t like to do that. 

Benardo: I know! Some people don’t like to think about what’s not in the script. But because Karin [Slaughter] adapted her own story – she adapted all six episodes, wrote them all – and there’s not not a lot of departures from the book. So, reading the book as a part of my research to get to the core of some of these things and get even more information was great. And it was such a page turner. 

You’re working with some wonderful actors in this show. Were there any particularly memorable days or scenes to shoot? 

Benardo: I got to shoot a scene with Brendan Gleeson, the legend – the man, the myth, the legend. He’s the nicest guy you can possibly meet. He’s so generous and kind. People are a little bit nervous around him, but he just totally brushes it off and gives everyone a big bear hug. We were sitting there filming the scene – you can’t hear what we were saying, so we had X pages of just dialogue to have going. And they told us to improv if we ran out of words. 

So we got to talking in character. I was like, “I’m not that great at school.” He goes, “I remember what I was like in school. I was handsome.” And I go, “Oh, really? What happened?” He wasn’t expecting that! And then they yelled cut, and he was – think I got him with that one. I joked to my friends, I was like, “That’s my best friend, Brendan Gleeson!” He’s such a class act. 

What are your feelings heading into the premiere of the show?

Benardo: I’m going into this with a really open mind. I mean, I am protective of Kelly, and I know how I feel about things at the end of the day. But these are really controversial and topical themes. So I’m totally open to whatever reaction people will have to the show. I hope that they take positive things away from it, because it is a story about transcending these harsh realities that a lot of us go through. I’m interested to see what the feedback will be and how well the team tackled these topics with so much care and respect and research.

All episodes of “The Good Daughter” are streaming on Peacock. 

Sammie Purcell is Associate Editor at Rough Draft Atlanta where she writes about arts & entertainment, including editing the weekly Scene newsletter.