There’s been a sharp increase in the cost of ingredients since the pandemic. While restaurants already operate on thin margins, rising ingredient and fuel costs, along with navigating complicated tariffs, mean the budget is tighter than ever. Not to mention factoring in overhead expenses like rent, utilities, and labor.

Welcome to “The Breakdown.” This by-the-numbers series examines the costs behind creating one specific dish from a local restaurant, providing you with a glimpse into what it takes to make it and why you pay what you pay.

For this installment, we’re breaking down the costs for making the 12-inch, pepper-ladened pizza from Firewall ATL in Westview.

Firewall ATL's peppers pizza uses local peppers, which leads to cost fluctuations.
A 12-inch peppers pizza from Firewall ATL retails for $16. (Provided by Firewall ATL)

More from The Breakdown series:
• The Breakdown: Minhwa Spirits’ smash burger
• The Breadown: Las Brasas’ Peruvian rotesserie chicken

Peppers pizza at Firewall

The peppers pizza at Firewall ATL is one of the Westview restaurant’s top orders. It’s also one of the most difficult dishes to price, due to fluctuations in the growing season, which affects the cost of peppers.

Firewall sources all of its ingredients locally and can pay up to a 50-cent difference on cherry bomb and habanada peppers, depending on the grower. Cheese for Firewall’s pizzas is sourced from Sweet Grass Dairy in Thomasville, Georgia.

But the majority of the cost to make this pizza comes down to labor. Firewall’s pizza dough requires a two-day proofing process that includes both working with the dough and monitoring it while it rises

“We’ve got to baby [the dough] a bit and make sure it’s perfect, working it periodically and then watching to make sure it’s sitting right,” said Caitlin Perdue, HERO Brands’ (Bovino After Dark, 7th House) director of business development.

Because Firewall uses a wood-fired pizza oven, the restaurant must also source logs from Dixie Firewood and Logs for the cooking process. The restaurant averages two logs per pizza at a cost of $2.50.

Firewall sells its 12-inch peppers pizza for $16, netting a profit ranging from $3.75 to $4.25 per pie.

Cost estimates below provided by Firewall ATL.

Ingredient costs per item

  • Dough: $0.50
  • Sauce: $0.25
  • Peppers: $1.50 to $2.00 (based on market fluctuations)
  • Cheese: $0.50

The breakdown

  • Ingredients: $2.75 to $3.25 (based on market fluctuations)
  • Staff and labor costs: $6.00
  • Wood: $2.50
  • Rent and utilities: $0.50
  • Total cost to make: $11.75 to $12.25 (based on market fluctuations)
  • You pay: $16
  • Remaining operating margin (profit): $3.75 to $4.25

Want us to break down the cost of your favorite local restaurant dish? Send an email to beth@roughdraftatlanta.com with your suggestions.

Sarra Sedghi is an award-winning dining reporter for Rough Draft Atlanta where she also covers events and culture around the 2026 FIFA World Cup.