“The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” film has about as difficult a task as the book did: How do you tell a compelling story about Haymitch Abernathy – Katniss’ drunk, damaged, and lonely mentor from the original “Hunger Games” trilogy – without the whole endeavor turning into nothing but a complete and total downer? 

It’s a difficult task, and one that the book manages to achieve in part (it is still quite the downer) by turning the reality of what we think we know on its head. Suzanne Collins’ book is a story about the beginnings of a movement that eventually ended with Katniss Everdeen, showing us that revolution was in the hearts of tributes forced to compete in the Games long before she ever drew her bow. The novel, then, turns into a compelling story not just about one man’s trauma, but about how for one rebellion to succeed, multiple must fail. 

Directed by Francis Lawrence, the movie is more of a mixed bag, sanding down some of the more interesting aspects of the characters and favoring the sadness of Haymitch’s story over the seeds of the revolutionary one. But, it’s still a solid entry in a franchise that has a pretty good track record, offering well-acted and well-made, smart entertainment for young adults. 

Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. (Photo courtesy of Lionsgate)
Joseph Zada as Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. (Photo courtesy of Lionsgate)

The Haymitch (Joseph Zada) we meet in “Sunrise on the Reaping” is very different from the one Woody Harrelson portrays in the original trilogy. He’s a loving brother and son, charming and kind with a bit of a bad boy streak (he brews alcohol for a bootlegger, but notably doesn’t drink himself). He’s got himself a girl, Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak), whom he sneaks off to meet in the meadow everyday. He’s a pretty lucky guy, all things considered – until, through a series of rather unlucky, bloody events, he finds himself a tribute in the Hunger Games. 

Haymitch starts on his journey to rebel more quickly than Katniss, almost immediately joining up with a group of mentors and other tributes to try and take down the Capitol for good. We know how Haymitch’s story ends, so we know this initial run at authority doesn’t pan out. But, the best parts of the film – particularly the moments where Haymitch interacts with Capitol cameraman-turned-rebel Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons) and President Snow himself (Ralph Fiennes) – are the moments where the seeds of revolution are planted. 

The movie, unfortunately, doesn’t give as much time to the start of the revolution as it does to Haymitch and the magnitude of his loss – which is all fairly well done, if sanded down a bit from the far more violent and thorny novel. The novel does a better job at showing how Haymitch’s various losses play into the larger theme of rebellion – what, exactly, you stand to lose when you decide to stand for what’s right, and how hard it is to protect those around you. This is most clearly seen in the relationship between Haymitch and Maysilee (McKenna Grace), which is a bit less complicated in the film than it is in the book. Haymitch is more honest with Maysilee in the film than he is in the novel, which leads to an ending that, while still sad, is a little less cruel and a little less astute at showing how ruthless the world can be. 

While the film isn’t as complex as Collins’ novel, it’s still an entertaining ride filled with great performances, from both newcomers and established actors. As Haymitch, Zada has both a handle on the character’s rebel charm and vulnerabilities, and is particularly strong in the character’s more raw, emotional moments. The young cast is bolstered by capable older actors – a combination that this franchise, historically, has always excelled in finding. While “Sunrise on the Reaping” might not be quite as strong as some of its predecessors, it’s still a solid entry in the canon. 

Sammie Purcell is Associate Editor at Rough Draft Atlanta where she writes about arts & entertainment, including editing the weekly Scene newsletter.