At the beginning of “I Play Rocky,” we meet Mike Stallone (Anthony Ippolito), silhouetted against the darkness of a stage as he auditions for a role. 

He’s recognizably the Sylvester Stallone we all know (although, still calling himself Mike at this time), but he’s – somehow – a little more unpolished, a little awkward with the hint of a lisp. At one point, a casting director asks him to repeat a line, but gives him new words to add that all contain more “S” sounds, presumably only to make fun of him before kicking him out of the room, no offer in sight. 

This is the opening scene of an underdog story about one of the greatest underdog stories of all time – the making of “Rocky,” which catapulted unknown screenwriter and actor Sylvester Stallone into movie stardom. “I Play Rocky,” directed by Peter Farrelly and written by Peter Gamble, follows Stallone from his early days of failed auditions in New York to the premiere of “Rocky” in Los Angeles, playing close attention to all of the obstacles in Stallone’s way – from evil studio exes that want the movie to fail, to injuries on set, to selling his beloved dog so he can afford groceries. 

In the film "I Play Rocky," Anthony Ippolito recreates the moment where Sylvester Stallone grabs a bar overhead and leans forward over Talia Shire, wearing a white tanktop.
(L to R) Kiki Seto as Talia Shire and Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone in I PLAY ROCKY, from Amazon MGM Studios. (Photo by Claire Folger)

© 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

“I Play Rocky” is better than expected – to be more specific, it’s funnier than expected (as a representative of the aforementioned evil studio execs, Tracy Letts delivers a killer line reading every time he opens his mouth). And some of the things that happened on the “Rocky” set as depicted in the film – whether they’re real or exaggerated for dramatic effect – are genuinely compelling to watch. But, as with so many biopics, the film gets a lot of mileage not out of how good it is, but how much you love the thing it’s depicting. It’s bound to be a crowdpleaser. Your dad will love it. But, it’s mostly a pale imitation of something truly special. 

Watching “I Play Rocky,” I couldn’t help but be reminded of reading Barbra Streisand’s memoir, “My Name is Barbra.” That book is made up of a collection of anecdotes that basically have the same construction: Barbra wants to do something. Everyone around her tells her she’s wrong and/or crazy. She does it anyway. She is proven right in the end. 

That is, essentially, the Stallone story in a nutshell – and probably the story of a lot of great stars or artists fighting to prove their worth to a world that doesn’t quite understand them. When Stallone finally gets the “Rocky” script in front of a couple of producers, Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff (P.J. Byrne and Toby Kebbell), they want to give the lead role to an established star. But Stallone refuses – “I play Rocky,” he says. 

This forms the central tension of the first half of the film, with the studio offering Stallone unfathomable amounts of money to not star in the picture. It’s the kind of drama constructed to make you let out a low whistle each time the offer gets higher. But, considering we know how the “Rocky” story ends, it’s not drama that inherently contains a lot of tension. It’s the kind of story that probably works better in a celebrity memoir form (you can almost hear Stallone reading the audiobook, drawling out, “Can you believe it?”) than a cinematic one. 

The script becomes more entertaining toward the back half of the film when it delves into the pandemonium of making an independent movie (rather than the nitty gritty of negotiations that we all know the outcome of). But, “I Play Rocky” banks so much on your connection to the original film – going so far as to recreate scenes from it, shot for shot – that it ends up working against its own interests. 

Ippolito is an impressive Stallone stand-in, and sometimes, it can be uncanny how much he looks and sounds like him. But, the script isn’t really interested in asking him to go deeper than that – and, while it’s an impressive transformation, an impression doesn’t necessitate that you be a good actor. When the scene doesn’t call for him to recreate something we’ve seen before – such as the moment where Stallone sells his dog to a stranger in a grocery store – he’s able to be a little freer and more emotive in his performance. But as the film becomes more and more about recreating iconic “Rocky” moments, he’s given an impossible task, and bound by the performance that Stallone already gave 50 years ago – and one that Stallone did better. 

All of that to say, the problem with “I Play Rocky” is you just kind of wish you were watching “Rocky” instead. It can’t live up to its subject.

Sammie Purcell is Associate Editor at Rough Draft Atlanta where she writes about arts & entertainment, including editing the weekly Scene newsletter.